Plurk

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Twilight versus Harry Potter?




I just hate those people comparing Twilight to Harry Potter. It's just Twilight CANNOT be compared to Harry Potter people!!! First, HP is for kids and adults that are kids at heart and Twilight is for hopeless romantic/ romantic people. Second, HP is about friendship and family and Twilight is about teenage love. Third, HP is a cute and Edward is gorgeous vampire. I can't think of anything else to compare with these two book because Twilight is incomparable to Harry Potter.HP is the best book series ever made (for me). To be honest, I had two sleepless nights thinking which book is better and I think it's really HP. I'm not a twilight hater! I love twilight too, but not as much as i loved Harry Potter. 

I got these from Yahoo! answers. Twilight fans please don't get mad at me for posting these, i'm a twilight fan too! xP

1- J.K spent more than 15 years on her plot, which turned out to be fantastic. While Stephanie just dreamed about it and started writing, she didn't plan her plot, and mark my words this affected her plot severely.

2- J.K's writing is very captivating, it grips you like a hook and makes you read obsessively. While Stephanie's style of writing though some may find it good, is very weak, she uses the words too often and she writes three chapters each time she wants to describe how good looking Edward is.

3- J.K's series is not only intended for females or a specific age group, as you can see many children, teenagers and adults enjoy it. While Stephanie's saga is basically for young females who didn't read many books to be able to judge with a professional point of view, though I don't call myself a professional, nor am I belittling any reader.

4- J.K's plot is new, it is appealing, no one ever had that idea of a boy who lived due to amazing circumstances. Stephanie's plot isn't new, well I don't call human\vampire affection new, that is used in many books. Since vampires are known to be very seductive and lustful.

5- J.K's characters are very well imagined and described, you can relate to them and find them similar to who you are or people around you. Stephanie's characters well not all of them, but most, are very annoying and rather dimwitted, I wish not to relate to them to tell you the truth.


(http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080607080437AAX1SHE)